Candidate for reviewOpen to critique and independent review

Constitutional assessment framework

Material and informational conditions of freedom

Which rights and duties provide the material, educational and informational conditions needed to exercise freedom effectively?

An example before the detail

Education unusable because of language or accessibility

Assumption: a family seeks usable mother-tongue education for a child with accessibility needs; the administration invokes the official status of a language, insufficient funding or later provision.

Asadi draft

Education, language freedom and some provision duties have support.

It remains unclear how these protections become a specific entitlement to a language of instruction or service, a general free interpreter, responsibility for costs and urgent protection for this child. The specific deadline for removing passage barriers in Article 123 does not extend to all rights.

Left draft

Recognition of language, equal protection and education rules provide a starting point.

Mother-tongue education in the specific case, language services and adequate resources have not yet been established. Cost allocation in Article 117 does not by itself create an individual entitlement to every service.

Combining state or provincial rules with general rights may provide the required protection; missing detail in the provisions read does not negate all language protection.

The child's actual attendance, quality and daily accessibility, and resource adequacy have not been observed.

Assumptions, findings and evidence for this example

Stepped houses on the mountainside in Masuleh
Masuleh, GilanPhotographer: Mojtaba Matboyi ↗

This category examines rights concerning work, subsistence, education, health, housing and usable information, together with responsibility for their adequate provision. The scope and timing of each entitlement and obligation must be specified separately.

Real conditions for exercising freedom

Which enforceable rights secure the material and informational conditions needed for effective freedom?

Individuals should have substantive rights to the material security, education, health, housing and usable information needed for effective freedom, with duties of adequate provision, specified guarantees and accountable responsibility for delivery.

What does this outcome examine?

  1. 1

    Decent work, fair pay, job security, social insurance and subsistence support, including during unemployment, disability and old age

  2. 2

    Quality education, preserving the manifesto commitment to free education and mother-tongue education alongside access to the shared language

  3. 3

    Health, adequate housing, clean water and air, and a healthy environment; environmental limits are also examined under O17

  4. 4

    Usable information and comprehensible services, including free written and oral translation and multilingual interfaces

  5. 5

    Responsible guarantors, sufficient resources and adequate provision; distinguishing immediate and progressive obligations where the source specifies them

Scope and limits of this outcome

The holders of each right are specified separately; entitlement is not conditional on proving inability to exercise freedom. Article 17 of Manifesto 10 names citizens concerning work and welfare, and Article 18 names everyone concerning health, housing and the environment. The distinction between immediate minimum guarantees and progressive full realization is specific to Article 18 rights and is not automatically generalized to all rights.

Transparent service administration without a substantive duty of adequate provision does not establish this condition. Free interpreting does not mean every public service is free. Adequacy and actual provision require implementation evidence.

Existing assessment at a glance

Findings remain provisional

Asadi draft

The text provides different protections for people in need, free education at all levels, basic health services and insurance. Further reading identifies the usual authority responsible for assistance in the state of residence and the duty to provide sufficient resources for state responsibilities. The five-year deadline for removing barriers to physical access concerns that specific duty; it does not permit all rights to be delayed. Adequate resources in practice, language access and implementation remain unresolved.

Read the full assessment and evidence ↗

Left draft

The text protects occupational freedom and unions and provides educational oversight and environmental protection. Article 117 allocates responsibility for costs; Article 124 allows specified spending to continue before a budget is approved. These rules alone do not give every person a right to every service or an adequate benefit. We still need to examine who is entitled to which service and how its quality, funding and language access are secured.

Read the full assessment and evidence ↗
Further explanation of the example

A hypothetical example to examine · PT01

Education unusable because of language or accessibility

Assumption: a family seeks usable mother-tongue education for a child with accessibility needs; the administration invokes the official status of a language, insufficient funding or later provision.

Follow the example through both drafts ↗
Rocks and water on the east coast of Chabahar
East coast of Chabahar, Sistan and BaluchestanPhotographer: Safa Daneshvar ↗

The photographs show places. They are not evidence of rights in practice or an endorsement of this project. Grayscale display and cropping are used for this concept.

Photographs and their sources

The photographs show places. They are not evidence of rights in practice or an endorsement of this project. Grayscale display and cropping are used for this concept.

Adaptations of photographs licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 are offered under the same license.