Candidate for reviewOpen to critique and independent review
An imagined group of women, men and non-binary adults dancing and laughing together in a club

Constitutional assessment framework

Introduction

A constitution must constrain power, especially when those exercising it resist limits. Trust in a political figure, even a monarch with a symbolic role, cannot replace rules and institutional guarantees.

Names such as republic, democracy or federalism do not by themselves tell us how power operates. Who makes a decision, who can challenge it, and how can a person obtain a remedy and secure compliance? Free and equal standing means that claiming rights does not depend on rulers’ favor and that no group has inferior standing in controlling power.

This project reads two drafts, Asadi and the identified Left text, through shared questions. It supports public criticism and revision. It gives no overall score and claims no authority to determine Iran’s future constitution.

A short path through the material

  1. Choose a topic

    Choose a concern that matters to you.

  2. Choose an outcome

    Identify the protection being examined; we call it an “outcome.”

  3. Read question and answers

    Read the drafts’ answers side by side. The comparison tool also lets you select just one text.

  4. Check evidence

    Open a question and its evidence. The return link takes you back to the related question or outcome.

Try an example: Outcome 10

The project’s full argument and purpose

A constitution should provide a binding framework for a future government: one that defines the powers and limits of every institution and officeholder and makes clear how people can hold them accountable. Upholding a constitution therefore means grounding restraints on power in rules and institutional guarantees. Trust in a political figure, even a monarch with a symbolic role, cannot replace those guarantees; that officeholder must also be subject to the constitution. A text alone does not restrain power. Its importance lies in the mechanisms it provides for public oversight, independent access to justice and remedies for violations, especially when those in power refuse to accept limits. This is where its effect on our lives becomes clear: can we oppose the government, challenge its decisions and claim our rights without depending on anyone’s favor or personal will?

For the same reason, a proposed structure of government should not be judged simply by its name, whether federalism, republicanism, democracy or any other label. The test is how it distributes power, what limits it places on its exercise, and what mechanisms allow people affected by decisions to hold those exercising power accountable.

To apply this test, this edition examines two Iranian constitutional drafts, Asadi and the identified republication of the Left draft, through shared questions: who holds power, who can restrain it, and how can a citizen seek a hearing, a remedy and enforcement when a right is violated?

The baseline is the free and equal standing of every person. Enjoying and pursuing a right should not depend on the favor of those in power. Language, gender, religion or national belonging should not place anyone in an inferior position when claiming rights or exercising control over power.

Start with one issue. Read the texts’ answers and relevant sections, and consider where explanation or revision is needed. The aim is to support criticism and discussion. The comparison gives no overall scores and welcomes criticism and independent review.

This project compares different Iranian constitutional drafts not to rank them or declare one text “better,” but to make the architecture of power visible and to create room for public criticism, discussion and revision.

A constitution is not evaluated simply by counting the rights it names. The frequency of words such as “freedom,” “equality” or “human rights” does not show how those rights are guaranteed: who holds power, who can restrain it, how a citizen can challenge a decision, what happens when a responsible institution fails to act, and whether persistent disagreement can remain inside a lawful political order without exclusion, violence or institutional blockage.

The project also does not presume the legitimacy of any draft and claims no authority to determine Iran’s future constitution. The underlying question is how legitimacy claims can be exposed to public examination. Legitimacy is therefore not only a property of a text; it also depends on a process in which questions can be raised, answers documented, objections recorded, and a draft explained or revised in response to public criticism.

The tool is intended to make that process visible: criteria should be clear, each draft’s answer should be traceable, ambiguities and unresolved issues should be documented, and proposed improvements should themselves be open to renewed examination. The cycle is: criterion → public examination → objection and criticism → response → revision → examination again.

No indicator or single question creates legitimacy by itself. These criteria are not intended to produce a “legitimacy score”; they make public the questions that a claim to legitimacy must be able to answer.

From a commitment to rights to examining a draft

Before examining a text, we need to say what we want it to protect and why. We then ask what powers the text grants and how they can be controlled. The following elements do different but connected jobs:

  1. What should be protected, and why?

    Manifestos

    The manifestos state this project’s commitments and reasons, including freedom from domination and equal standing. These guide our judgments and can themselves be challenged.

  2. What are we talking about?

    Concepts and relationships / Ontology

    A person’s right, an institution’s duty, a power to decide and a remedy are different things. Distinguishing them and their relationships helps us avoid mistaking the promise of a right for the ability to claim and enforce it.

  3. How do we find the issues?

    Organization of issues / Taxonomy

    Nine topics help readers find related concerns and gaps in coverage. Classification alone does not establish that a goal is desirable.

  4. What protection are we looking for?

    Outcomes / برآیندها

    An outcome is a proposed condition or protection to examine, such as effective access to justice. It does not mean a result already achieved in society.

  5. How do we establish what the text provides?

    Questions and evidence

    We connect a specific question to provisions, source versions and the relevant reading. We then state what has support, what is expressly left to later legislation and what remains unresolved within the scope examined.

Turning manifesto commitments into assessable outcomes requires interpretation. We distinguish explicit commitments from our reading and proposed extensions. Accepting a broad goal does not automatically mean accepting every institutional design.

We reuse CCP-FACET in the Sartori repository as an external reference for concepts and coverage. It does not determine the project’s values. We claim neither a new ontology nor a demonstrated complete formal mapping of all identifiers to that reference.

Some conditions are examined separately because one does not secure the other. Adequate education or health care is related to freedom from dominating dependence, but they are distinct: a service may exist while access still depends on pleasing someone with power. The twenty outcomes are a revisable analytical organization for this project, not twenty independent scores or an exhaustive national standard.

CCP-FACET / Sartori

This edition has 218 questions: 174 original questions and 44 additions to examine gaps in coverage. The recorded answers to the original questions are retained; not all additional questions have equally complete paired assessments. The original questionnaire’s seven groups and the framework’s nine topics are different ways of organizing and reading the material, not separate sets of answers.

Provisional reading; open to critique and independent review

What if an agency refuses to obey a ruling?

Hypothetical example: a person obtains a ruling against a government agency, but the agency refuses to comply. This is a test situation, not a report of an observed event.

  1. Underlying commitment

    Claiming a right should not depend on the favor of those exercising power.

  2. Expected protection

    A person can challenge a decision, obtain a suitable remedy and pursue compliance. This is part of effective access to justice under Outcome 10.

  3. Diagnostic question

    Who must enforce the ruling? If the government refuses, which body can compel it, by what means and within what time?

  4. Evidence needed

    Read separately the rules on a ruling’s binding effect, the duty to comply, the right to challenge refusal and the reviewing body’s powers. Each needs its own source version and reference.

  5. Bounded conclusion

    A duty to comply is different from a mechanism capable of securing compliance in the face of refusal. Establishing one does not establish the other or prove that it works in practice.

Asadi draft

In the Asadi reading, Article 187 requires the federal government to enforce Supreme Court judgments. The means to compel the refusing government itself still need examination.

Left draft

In the Left reading, a ruling’s legal effect under Article 106(2) is distinguished from enforcement. Compelling a province under Article 37 is also not a general route for an individual against the federal government.

This synthesis is provisional. Failure to identify a mechanism within the scope examined does not prove its absence throughout the text or the failure of the whole draft.

Where can your criticism begin?

Identify the question, provision, interpretation or criterion you dispute and explain why. If you have another source, give its version and precise location. You do not need a complete alternative constitution to contribute.

The proposed process is a specific objection, examination of the evidence and a response, reasons for accepting or rejecting the criticism, and a recorded revision in the next edition. This is the intended process. This edition does not operate a public submission and tracking service.

Basis, method and limits

The project’s wider purpose

A new social contract for an Iran free from domination

A project developing manifestos and public conversations for a people-centred future founded on freedom, equality and dignity.

Start here

Read the texts, follow the conversations and contribute your criticism.

9Topics
20Outcomes
218Questions
Stepped houses on the mountainside in Masuleh
Masuleh, GilanPhotographer: Mojtaba Matboyi ↗

One topic to begin with

Material and informational conditions of freedom

Which rights and duties provide the material, educational and informational conditions needed to exercise freedom effectively?

Read this topic’s introduction ↗

Topics to explore

Choose a topic, then follow its outcomes, questions and supporting evidence.

  1. 1Does everyone have equal standing and protection, and can they maintain their liberties and identity?Equal standing, liberties and recognition of identities
  2. 2How do people authorize rulers, replace them and influence decisions between elections?Democratic authority, participation and public control
  3. 3How are fundamental rules formed and changed with public participation, and how do they protect rights during transition?Making and changing a constitution
  4. 4What limits power, and how can people defend their rights and demand that remedies be implemented?Safeguards, oversight and effective remedies
  5. 5How can communities govern their own affairs while protecting the rights of their members and others?Collective self-government and shared rights
  6. 6Which rights and duties provide the material, educational and informational conditions needed to exercise freedom effectively?Material and informational conditions of freedom
  7. 7What prevents economic dependence from placing individuals or public decisions under uncontrolled power?Economic power and dependence
  8. 8How should today's decisions protect the environment, future generations' freedom and fairness between regions?Environmental, intergenerational and interregional responsibilities
  9. 9How can society avoid subjection to uncontrolled foreign power and avoid dominating other societies?Foreign relations and non-domination in both directions

Method and hypothetical scenarios

Flowcharts for the assessment

Follow the paths and open questions, from the methodology cycle to language rights, enforcement and deadlocks in judicial appointments, in Persian and English.

The institutional scenarios are provisional proposals, not adopted constitutional text.

Explore the flowcharts and method ↗
Detailed definitions and assessment basis

The project’s existing concepts and definitions

The basis of this assessment

A taxonomy alone does not establish that an outcome is desirable; its justification comes from the normative basis. Nor does the ontology replace the author's value judgments. This edition does not claim to create a new ontology or formally and comprehensively map every identifier to the existing reference.

Source versions and access limits ↗
1Manifestos
Normative basis

What should be guaranteed, and why? The author's manifestos provide the normative basis for this assessment.

2Ontology
Conceptual reference

Which concepts are we examining, and how are they related? We reuse the existing CCP-FACET reference in the Sartori repository.

3Taxonomy
Organization of issues

How do we categorize issues for examination? The taxonomy belongs to this project; the current nine-topic formulation is a provisional proposal in this draft, based on the author's work.

4Outcomes
Assessable conditions

What condition should hold, for whom, and under which institutions' responsibility? The proposed outcomes translate manifesto commitments into assessable conditions.

5Diagnostic questions
How to examine the evidence

What should we look for in a constitutional text to assess each condition? Questions link to outcomes; the presence of a question does not establish that its outcome is achieved.

Rocks and water on the east coast of Chabahar
East coast of Chabahar, Sistan and BaluchestanPhotographer: Safa Daneshvar ↗
Photographs and their sources

The opening image imagines a possible future in Iran. It does not depict real people or a documented event. The photographs of places below retain their photographer and source credits.

Adaptations of photographs licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 are offered under the same license.